A female caregiver smiles and holds the hands of an older woman in a yellow sweater as she steadies her.

Choosing self-directed care means you or a loved one get to decide who provides your support. For many families, that is the biggest reason they choose self-direction in the first place. Some people choose someone they already know and trust, while others look for someone new.

In most programs, you (or a representative acting on your behalf) become your caregiver’s employer. If you have never hired or managed anyone before, that can feel like a lot. The good news is that you do not have to handle it alone. Self-directed programs are built with support in place, including help with payroll, taxes, and paperwork.

Before you start: To hire a caregiver through self-direction, you first need to be eligible for and enrolled in a Medicaid program (or another publicly funded program) that offers self-direction, and have your services approved. Eligibility rules, covered services, and whether self-direction is available at all vary by state and program. You will also have an assessment to determine the services you need and are approved for. Your state Medicaid agency, health plan, or case manager is the best place to start.

Not sure what self-direction is or how it works? Start here: Understanding Self-Directed Care.

There are generally three ways people arrange in-home care, and each one handles the employer role differently:

  • Home care agency: The agency hires, trains, schedules, and supervises the caregiver, and handles payroll and taxes. You do not choose the specific person who comes to your home.
  • Private hire on your own: You find and employ a caregiver directly and pay them yourself. You have full control, but you are also responsible for all employer tasks, including payroll, tax withholding, and filings.
  • Self-direction: You choose and direct your caregiver, and your care is paid for through your program, which is usually Medicaid-funded. A Financial Management Services (FMS) provider, sometimes also called a fiscal intermediary (FI), handles the payroll, tax, and paperwork side for you.

Self-direction combines the choice of hiring on your own with the support of a program that handles the administrative work. Keep in mind that self-directed programs vary by state, including who you can hire, how pay rates are set, and what employer responsibilities you take on.

Many people in self-direction choose a family member as their caregiver, and for good reason: they already know you and your routines. Wondering what it really means to be a family caregiver? Hear stories from people who do it every day.

Before you look for a caregiver, it helps to know what support you or your loved one needs, and that starts with an assessment. As part of enrollment, a qualified professional, such as a nurse, case manager, or care coordinator depending on your state and program, will assess your needs. This is sometimes called a clinical or functional assessment. It looks at what kind of help you need, how much, and which tasks can be done safely by a caregiver. It also identifies any tasks that need to be done by a licensed professional.

The results are used to build your person-centered plan (or similar plan, such as a service plan or plan of care, depending on your program), which you develop with your case manager or care coordinator. Your plan outlines the services you are approved for and typically determines your authorized hours or budget.

Once you have your plan, it still helps to write out what a typical day looks like. Your plan sets the framework, and your list fills in the everyday details. Consider tasks like:

  • Bathing, dressing, and grooming
  • Meal preparation and eating
  • Medication reminders
  • Mobility and transfers
  • Light housekeeping and laundry
  • Errands, appointments, and transportation
  • Companionship and community activities

Your list will help you write a clear job description, ask better interview questions, and set expectations from day one. Keep in mind that your caregiver can only provide the services approved in your plan. Some tasks, like skilled or medical tasks, may be limited or may need to be handled by a licensed professional, so confirm with your case manager what your caregiver is allowed to do. If your needs change, ask about getting your plan reassessed.

Your assessment and plan also help determine your budget or authorized hours. Depending on your program, you may have a set number of approved care hours, an individual dollar budget, or both. Take time to understand what you have been approved for before you start hiring, and ask your case manager if anything is unclear. In some programs, you can decide how much to pay your caregiver within your budget. In others, the program sets the pay rate.

Many programs also have rules about overtime or the maximum number of hours one caregiver can work, and your caregiver’s hours must stay within what you are approved for. In some programs, employer-related taxes are also paid out of your budget. Before you build a schedule or agree on pay (if your program lets you set it), ask your case manager or FMS provider how these rules apply to you.

In most self-directed programs, you, or a representative acting on your behalf, become the employer of your caregiver. This is often called the Fiscal/Employer Agent model. Some states instead use an Agency with Choice model, where an agency is the legal employer while you still choose and direct your caregiver. 

As the employer, your responsibilities can include:

  • Recruiting, interviewing, and selecting your caregiver
  • Training your caregiver on your specific needs and preferences
  • Setting and managing the work schedule
  • Supervising day-to-day care
  • Reviewing and approving timesheets
  • Arranging backup coverage when your caregiver is unavailable
  • Ending the working relationship if it is not the right fit

If you are not able to handle these responsibilities on your own, many programs allow you to choose a representative, often a trusted family member or friend, to help. Some programs do not allow the same person to be both your representative and your paid caregiver.

Many people who self-direct hire someone they already know, like an adult child, sibling, friend, or neighbor who is already helping. That familiarity can make care feel more comfortable and personal from the start. Consistent support from someone you trust can also make a real difference in emotional well-being, which we explore in our blog, “The Emotional Support Benefits of In-Home Caregivers.”

Before you commit, confirm that your program allows you to pay that person. Rules about which relatives can be paid caregivers vary by state and program, especially for spouses, parents of minor children, and legal guardians.

Hiring someone you know also works best when you treat it as a real job. Talk openly about duties, schedules, and expectations, and put them in writing. Clear boundaries can help protect the relationship on both sides, and they make it easier to spot and prevent caregiver burnout before it affects either of you.

If you need to hire someone you do not already know, a few places to start include:

  • Personal recommendations from family, friends, neighbors, or your faith community
  • Your case manager or care coordinator, who may know of local resources
  • Local disability, aging, or independent living organizations
  • Caregiver directories, which some states and programs offer to help participants connect with available workers
  • Social media and community groups, such as local Facebook groups, neighborhood boards, or community forums, where you can post that you are looking for a caregiver and see who is interested

Casting a wide net can help you find people you might not have come across otherwise. Once you hear from interested candidates, you can interview them to see who is the right fit. When posting publicly, it is a good idea to leave out personal details like your home address or health information, and share those only once you have chosen to move forward with someone.

A good interview goes beyond a resume. Ask questions that help you understand how the person thinks and how they would handle real situations. For example:

  • Can you tell me about your experience providing care?
  • Why are you interested in this type of work?
  • What would you do if I refused a meal or did not want to take my medication?
  • What would you do if I lost my balance or fell?
  • How would you handle a day when you are running late or cannot make it?
  • Are you comfortable with the specific tasks this role requires?

Call references when possible, especially past employers or people they have provided care for. If your program or care needs require specific credentials, such as CPR certification or a driver’s license for transportation, ask to see them.

Pay attention to fit as well as experience. Communication style, reliability, and how the person interacts with you or your loved one matter a great deal over time.

Once you have chosen your caregiver, they will need to complete enrollment with your program before they can start working and be paid. This may feel like a mountain of work, but your FMS provider will help guide you through the process. You don’t have to do this alone.

The exact steps, forms, and timelines vary by state and program, so your care team will let you know what applies to you. In general, caregiver onboarding includes:

  • Federal and state tax withholding forms, such as IRS Form W-4
  • USCIS Form I-9 and supporting documents to confirm eligibility to work in the U.S.
  • A payment method form for direct deposit or another option
  • A background check (most programs require one)
  • Required training or health screenings, depending on your program
  • Any program-specific forms, such as a caregiver agreement

Most programs require a background check before a caregiver can start working and be paid. Which records are reviewed, what may disqualify someone, and who pays for the check vary by state and program.

It is also a good idea to create a simple written work agreement, even if your program does not require one. Include the caregiver’s duties, schedule, pay rate, how to request time off, and any household rules. Having it in writing helps prevent misunderstandings later.

As the employer, you decide when your caregiver works, within the hours or budget your program has approved. A consistent schedule helps both of you plan and creates a predictable routine, which can be especially valuable for people who benefit from structure.

A few tips for managing hours well:

  • Stay within your authorized hours or budget. Hours worked beyond what is approved may not be paid through your program.
  • Keep an eye on overtime rules. If your program limits hours or overtime, plan schedules with that in mind.
  • Build a backup plan. Caregivers get sick, have emergencies, and take vacations. Some people hire more than one caregiver or identify a backup person ahead of time, if their program allows it.
  • Communicate changes early. If your needs or schedule change, let your caregiver know as soon as possible, and contact your case manager if you may need a change to your approved hours.

Accurate timekeeping is how your caregiver gets paid correctly and on time. In most programs, your caregiver records their hours, and you or your representative review and approve them.

Under federal law, states must use electronic visit verification (EVV) for Medicaid personal care services and home health care services that require an in-home visit. In many programs, this means your caregiver clocks in and out using a mobile app or a phone system that records the date, time, and location of the visit. Your program will explain which system to use.

A few timekeeping habits help prevent pay delays:

  • Review and approve time promptly, before your program’s deadline
  • Check that the hours recorded match the hours worked
  • Address missed clock-ins or errors right away

Your FMS provider’s got this covered. Once time is approved, they process your caregiver’s pay using the funds in your approved budget. It also withholds and files employment taxes, which can include federal, state, local, and unemployment taxes, and tracks how much of your budget or authorized hours you have used.

You do not need to run payroll or file employment taxes yourself, but you do stay in charge of approving time and directing care.

A good working relationship takes ongoing attention. Small habits go a long way:

  • Hold regular check-ins. A short weekly or monthly conversation about what is going well and what could improve helps catch small issues early.
  • Update expectations as needs change. If health, mobility, or routines change, adjust your caregiver’s tasks, and let your case manager know if your plan needs updating.
  • Give feedback respectfully. Be specific, and recognize what your caregiver does well.
  • Respect boundaries. This matters even more when your caregiver is a family member or friend.

Sometimes, a caregiver relationship does not work out. As the employer in most self-directed programs, you have the right to end it. If that happens, contact your FMS provider and case manager so they can help with the steps to end employment and bring on someone new.

Need a more in-depth look at getting started? Our guide, “How to Get Enrolled in Self-Directed Care,” gives you a high-level overview of the enrollment process.

Hiring and managing your own caregiver is a big part of self-direction, and it comes with real rewards, including more choice, more flexibility, and care from someone you trust. If you are wondering whether self-directed care is a good fit for you or a loved one, take our short questionnaire to see your next steps. If you are already enrolled, you can find your state program for program-specific guides, forms, and timekeeping resources.

Public Partnerships (PPL) is a Financial Management Services provider focused entirely on self-directed care. We support approximately 50 self-directed programs across the country and have supported more than 700,000 participant and caregiver relationships. PPL is not a home care agency and does not assign caregivers or provide direct care. Instead, we help participants and caregivers through enrollment, process caregiver payroll, handle employment tax requirements, and offer easy-to-use tools for timekeeping and electronic visit verification, so you can focus on directing your care. Have questions? Contact us anytime.

To take part in self-directed care, you generally need to be eligible for and enrolled in a Medicaid program (or another publicly funded program) that offers self-direction. You will also have an assessment to determine the services you need and are approved for. Eligibility rules and availability vary by state and program, so your state Medicaid agency, health plan, or case manager is the best place to start.

Start with your assessment and person-centered plan, which determine your approved services and your hours or budget. Then choose and interview a caregiver who is allowed under your program’s rules. Your caregiver then completes enrollment paperwork and any required background check or training. They can begin working once their enrollment is complete and your services are authorized.

With a home care agency, the agency typically hires, trains, schedules, and supervises the caregiver, and handles payroll and taxes. You may have limited say in who is assigned to you. With self-direction, you choose and direct your caregiver, such as a family member or friend if your program allows it, and a Financial Management Services (FMS) provider supports you with payroll, taxes, and paperwork. In most programs you (or your representative) are the employer, which means you take on more responsibility in exchange for more choice.

Ask about their caregiving experience, their availability, and their comfort with the specific tasks you need help with. Scenario questions, like what they would do if you fell or refused a meal, can show how they handle real situations.

Related posts